Why The Guess Who Deserve Their Place in the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame – A Very Canadian Perspective

It’s been over half a century since The Guess Who first hit airwaves with their distinctive blend of rock, blues, and pop, becoming one of the most successful bands to ever emerge from Canada. Yet, in a puzzling oversight, the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame still hasn’t welcomed them into its storied ranks. For Canadians, this omission doesn’t just feel like a snub to a band — it feels like a snub to a piece of our cultural identity.

Let’s start with the numbers. Between 1968 and 1975, The Guess Who charted over a dozen hit singles on the Billboard Hot 100, including timeless classics like “These Eyes,” “American Woman,” “No Time,” “Undun,” and “Share the Land.” “American Woman” became the first song by a Canadian band to hit No. 1 in the United States — a feat that cracked open the door for generations of Canadian musicians to follow.

But it wasn’t just about chart positions. The Guess Who helped put Canadian rock music on the international map. Long before the days of CanCon (Canadian content) regulations, this band was the blueprint, showing the world that Canadian music could be every bit as raw, soulful, and chart-topping as anything coming out of New York or London. They sang with a perspective that felt both universal and unmistakably northern. In a time of U.S. turmoil, The Guess Who — from the frozen streets of Winnipeg, Manitoba — delivered “American Woman” as both a protest and a mirror held up to the States. It was bold. It was real. And it still hits today.

And then there’s Burton Cummings, arguably one of the finest vocalists in rock history, with a range and tone that made every line feel like gospel. Pair him with Randy Bachman’s guitar brilliance, and you’ve got one of the most dynamic songwriting duos of the era. Their records weren’t just hits — they were masterclasses in melody, arrangement, and storytelling.

Canada has always punched above its weight in music, but The Guess Who were the heavyweights who showed the world we had something to say. They’re not just a great Canadian band — they’re a great band, period. If we’re talking legacy, influence, musicianship, and cultural impact, The Guess Who check every box.

The Rock & Roll Hall of Fame says it exists to recognize artists who have had a significant impact on the evolution, development, and perpetuation of rock and roll. Well, here’s the truth: The Guess Who didn’t just contribute — they helped define an era.

So let’s be polite, sure, but let’s also be loud about this: it’s long past time to induct The Guess Who into the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame. For the band, for Canadian music history, and for every snow-covered garage band that ever dared to dream big from north of the 49th.

Your move, Cleveland.